Fix: Blathers won’t accept Sea Creatures – Animal Crossing New Horizons

In this guide, we will show you how to fix the issue with Blathers if it won’t accept Sea Creatures. New Horizons is the fifth installment in the Animal Crossing series that made its way earlier this year. Although this life-simulation game is only available for Nintendo Switch, yet there hasn’t been any dent in its popularity. Assuming the role of a customizable character, the game gives you the option to explore the island. Apart from that, you could gather and craft items, catch fish and insects, and do everything within your reach to survive and earn for a living.

All these are definitely pretty challenging it its own right. But none comes close to the current issue that quite a lot of users are facing as of late. They are reporting that Blathers won’t accept Sea Creatures in New Horizons. If you are one of those players who are stuck in this mission set, then this guide will come in handy. We will list out all the possible reasons as to why this refusal is happening in the first place. Furthermore, we will also list out a workaround to rectify this issue at the earliest. So without further ado, let’s begin.

Fix: Blathers won’t accept Sea Creatures - Animal Crossing New Horizons

Fix: Blathers won’t accept Sea Creatures – Animal Crossing New Horizons

If Blathers Owl isn’t accepting any of your donations, then there could be a couple of reasons for the same. The first reason could be the fact that you might have not given any fossil to the owl yet. For the unawares, you have to make at least one fossil donation to Blathers before he accepts your offerings.

If you are thinking where you could find these fossils, then you might have to do a little inspection. Take up your shovel, and head over to a place on the ground where you could see a black star symbol. This shouldn’t be a tough nut to crack considering there are many such spots throughout the game.


Anyways, moving on, once you give the fossil to Blathers, the museum will then accept your Sea Creatures. Talking about the latter, there exists fish, sharks, and turtles in the form of these creatures. All of them could easily be caught using a fishing rod and could then be taken to the museum, from where the owl could have a look at them and give a nod towards this offering of yours.

Other Reasons for Refusal

In some cases, even if you have given him the fossils, Blathers might still not accept Sea Creatures. The reason this time could be attributed to the fact that you have already donated that specimen. He only accepts one specie of each animal in the Critterpedia. If you have more than one, then the best bet will be to sell them out.

sea creatures

Now, once you keep both these points in mind, your offering will be given an affirmatively reply. Once accepted, you could view all of them from the museum’s aquarium area. More often than not, they could be found swimming around. Furthermore, you could even ask Blathers regarding further details about all the species that you have donated.

With this, we conclude the guide on how to fix the issue with Blathers if it won’t accept Sea Creatures. Just keep in mind to donate a fossil and never donate the same species of any creature twice. You should then have no issues whatsoever with regards to this challenge. Rounding off, here are some iPhone Tips and TricksPC tips and tricks, and Android Tips and Trick that you should check out as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.